Technology
The end of selling seats? Why the CX technology and BPO industries are converging
As CX technology vendors and business process outsourcers (BPOs) reposition themselves as AI orchestration companies, the traditional boundaries between the two industries are beginning to blur. But are businesses ready for the pace of change?
I recently attended a Genesys Partner event where the go-to-market message was unmistakable: “We are not selling seats any more.”
That’s a significant statement from a multi-billion-dollar CX technology company whose traditional business model has been built around licensing software according to the number of human contact centre agents using it.
Genesys is now positioning itself as an AI orchestration company, increasingly selling outcomes and business value rather than agent licences. Some deals may not involve a single human agent licence.
What makes this particularly interesting is that I heard almost exactly the same message a month earlier at BPO Exchange, an event for the business process outsourcing industry. Large CX BPOs were delivering the same message: “We are not selling seats any more.” They, too, are repositioning themselves as AI orchestration businesses, offering solutions that may involve no human agents at all.
Two traditionally distinct industries, both targeting the same enterprise customers, are converging on an almost identical go-to-market strategy.
And that raises some interesting questions about the future of the CX industry.
From selling capacity to selling outcomes
Historically, both CX technology providers and BPOs have largely sold capacity. For technology vendors, that meant software licences based on the number of contact centre agents. For BPOs, it meant selling human labour, most commonly priced as hourly rates. AI is challenging both models.
If an AI agent can handle thousands of customer interactions without requiring a corresponding increase in human headcount, why should the customer continue paying according to the number of seats? Instead, vendors are increasingly talking about consumption-based, outcome-based and value-based commercial arrangements.
The proposition is attractive: customers pay for what they consume, what gets resolved, or the business value delivered, rather than simply the resources deployed.
But moving to these models isn’t straightforward. Outcome-based pricing raises some difficult commercial questions.
Who owns the outcome when AI and humans share the customer journey? How do you define and measure success? What happens when interaction volumes fluctuate? And who pays when AI-driven interactions increase dramatically but don’t necessarily translate into valuable outcomes?
There’s also the question of price certainty. A change in pricing methodology doesn’t automatically mean a lower cost. As industry commentator David Stone observed, customers should be looking beyond whether they are paying by seats, outcomes, calls, minutes or seconds, and focusing instead on the amount they are actually paying for the service.
Consumption-based pricing can also come with minimum spend commitments and lengthy contracts. In an unpredictable environment, businesses need to understand how much flexibility they really have if customer volumes or channel preferences change.
I suspect we’ll see a range of commercial models coexist for some time, rather than one pricing model replacing all others.
The convergence of tech vendors and BPOs
Perhaps the more significant development is what this means for the competitive landscape. If a technology company is selling AI orchestration, automation and business outcomes, while a BPO is offering essentially the same, where does one industry end and the other begin?
Traditionally, technology vendors provided the platforms and BPOs provided the people to operate them. That distinction is becoming less clear.
Technology companies may increasingly acquire BPOs to gain operational expertise, delivery capability and customer relationships. Conversely, BPOs may look to acquire technology businesses to strengthen their AI capabilities and differentiate their offerings.
M&A activity is bound to increase in both directions.
The competitive landscape could look very different in a few years, with businesses choosing between technology-led, services-led and hybrid providers, rather than simply choosing between a software vendor and a BPO partner.
Is the pendulum swinging too far?
While agentic AI is the future, I can’t help feeling the pendulum is swinging too fast for many businesses, which still have core needs around contact centre platforms and human customer service teams.
Particularly in the SMB market, a majority of companies are still trying to get the fundamentals right: fixing broken customer journeys, policies which create unnecessary friction, and pricing issues. Automating a broken process can simply make a bad customer experience happen faster and more often.
There are also important questions around complaints, compliance and vulnerable customers. The customer remains at the heart of CX, regardless of how sophisticated the technology becomes.
The real test of this transformation won’t be how many interactions AI can handle. It will be whether customers experience better, faster and more effective service.
Business goals must come first
Ultimately, I believe businesses need to resist the temptation to start with the technology or the latest commercial model. Instead, they should start with their business goals and customer strategy, and from there determine the right mix of technology, human resources and outsourcing.
So who will win this race for market dominance?
As the CX technology and BPO industries converge, competition for “AI orchestration” offerings will intensify, and the winners may not necessarily be those with the best technology. I think the most likely winners will be those who offer:
- deep domain expertise, understanding the regulations, processes and best practices specific to an industry
- strong connections and brand awareness in the C-Suite – as AI is increasingly an enterprise-wide strategy, not confined to one department such as CX or IT
- proprietary tools and reusable models that can speed implementation and provide a point of differentiation
- the ability to integrate and orchestrate across multiple existing tech stacks
- accountability for outcomes, reflected in pricing and contractual frameworks
- robust security and governance, which build trust in the market
- top talent in solution design and professional services
- clarity on roles and processes where humans do a better job than AI, as well as a reimagination of the AI-enabled workforce
- and of course vendors who can reskill their sales teams and partners for the new world.
Enterprise giants such as Microsoft, Amazon, Google, Salesforce and Accenture would appear to be well-positioned, as are domain specialists and AI-native innovators.
Meanwhile, amidst all the AI hype, BPOs should not lose sight of the ongoing need for high-value, complex human services, from sales negotiation and telehealth to vulnerable customer management and financial advice. Those who try to swing the pendulum to full automation will not win this race.
